Car vs. Truck Rental: What’s Better for a Cottage Weekend in Muskoka?

Planning a long weekend escape to Muskoka? Whether you’re heading to the lake with family or packing up for a solo retreat, one big question often comes up:

Should you rent a car or a truck for your cottage getaway?

At Bristol Car and Truck Rentals, we help thousands of GTA residents find the best car rental for weekend adventures. Here’s a helpful guide to choosing between a car rental or truck rental for your next trip to Muskoka—especially during busy holiday weekends like Canada Day, Civic Holiday, or Labour Day.

When a Car Rental Makes More Sense

If you’re packing light or travelling solo or as a couple, a compact or mid-size car might be your best bet. Here’s why:

✅ Fuel Efficiency

  • Cars typically offer better fuel economy, which means more savings on that 2.5–3 hour drive from Toronto to Muskoka.

✅ Easier to Drive and Park

  • Navigating through smaller cottage roads or tight town parking is much easier in a car—especially in areas like Bracebridge or Huntsville.

✅ Cost-Effective

  • Car rentals generally come with lower base rates and mileage fees, making them ideal for budget-conscious travellers.

✅ Perfect For:

– * Solo travellers or couples

– * Short stays with minimal luggage

– * Day trips to cottage country

Pro Tip: Book early before long weekends—compact and mid-size cars are the first to sell out across GTA branches.

Why You Might Need a Truck Rental Instead

If you’re travelling with gear, tools, or the whole family, a pickup truck or moving truck rental could be the smarter choice.

✅ More Space

  • Pickup trucks come with large beds—perfect for carrying coolers, outdoor furniture, BBQs, or even kayaks.

✅ Heavy-Duty Capabilities

  • Planning to haul a trailer or boat? You’ll need the towing capacity and power that only a truck provides.

✅ Multi-Purpose Functionality

  • Trucks are great if you’re:
  •  

* Transporting items to or from your cottage

* Helping with reno projects

* Bringing bikes, ATVs, or camping gear

✅ Perfect For:

* Families or groups of 3+

* Extended stays

* Cottage owners doing supply runs

– Need a cargo van instead of a truck? Bristol offers cargo van rentals ideal for indoor items or if you want protection from the elements.

GTA to Muskoka: What Locals Are Booking

Based on trends from our 14+ locations across the Greater Toronto Area—including Toronto, Brampton, Mississauga, Markham, and Barrie—here’s what most renters choose:

* Car Rentals: Popular for quick, low-cost getaways

* Truck Rentals: Favoured by cottage owners, larger groups, or those doing DIY projects

 

What to Consider Before You Book

Here are a few things to keep in mind when deciding between a car or truck rental for your Muskoka weekend:

Factor

Car Rental

Truck Rental

Fuel Efficiency

✅ Excellent

❌ Lower fuel economy

Storage/Hauling Space

❌ Limited

✅ Great for gear and supplies

Comfort for Long Drives

✅ Smooth, quiet ride

✅ High seating, more visibility

Price

✅ More affordable

❌ Higher than cars

Parking & Handling

✅ Easier to maneuver

❌ Can be bulky on narrow roads

 Need Help Choosing? We’ve Got You.

Not sure whether a car or truck rental is right for you? At Bristol Car and Truck Rentals, we offer:

✅ Guaranteed bookings – no last-minute surprises

✅ Free vehicle upgrades when available

✅ Multiple pickup locations across the GTA

✅ Friendly, local staff ready to help

Long Weekend Offer: Save 10% on Compact & Mid-Size Cars

  • Use promo code SUMMER10 when booking your car rental for the upcoming long weekend. Perfect for Muskoka drives!
  •  

Book Early – Long Weekends Fill Up Fast

  • Whether you’re renting a car for a quick trip or a truck for a weekend project, Bristol has the right vehicle to get you there comfortably and affordably.
  •  

📍 Find us in Toronto, Brampton, Barrie, Richmond Hill, Markham, Milton, and more!

📅 Reserve now and make your Muskoka long weekend getaway stress-free. Plan smarter. Drive farther. Choose Bristol – Your Local Rental Experts.